Toward a Marshall Plan for Ukraine
Executive Summary
Emergency assistance for Ukraine was and is a necessity dictated by Russia’s war. Beginning with the London Recovery Conference in June 2023, the Ukraine alliance should adopt a more strategic view of Ukraine’s reconstruction, with an eye toward mid- and long-term planning. Five key enablers of reconstruction should be prioritized:
Private investment
At least initially, donors need to share the risk with investors and provide war insurance. A multilateral investment trust fund should be created to provide that insurance and complement national efforts. The fund should be open only to investors from countries that aid Ukraine during the war.
Energy transition
Ukraine’s shattered energy infrastructure should be rebuilt in accordance with the EU decarbonization goals, allowing the country’s economy to leapfrog into a net-zero future. Ukraine should join EU flagship climate policies soon and ahead of full bloc membership.
Russian assets
Frozen public funds should be temporarily invested, with the proceeds made available to Ukraine, and an international claims conference should be prepared to make Russia pay, albeit in a legal and transparent way, to directly aid those affected by Russian aggression.
Transparency and accountability
Continued aid must be conditioned upon continued anti-corruption reform. To ensure implementation, civil society needs to participate in a reconstruction process that adheres to decentralization principles.
Donor coordination
The new G7 Multi-agency Donor Coordination Platform for Ukraine needs to be better equipped to succeed. Its capacity for strategic planning should be added, and its leadership structure should be rethought.
Reversing Ukraine’s economic trajectory, uplifting its people, and enabling the country to integrate successfully into the European and world economy requires sustained, long-term growth. The recommendations in this report are enablers that will help to set Ukraine on the road to rapid recovery.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Creating War Insurance and Incentivizing Investment
Expand All1. Fund War Insurance
Create a risk-sharing investment trust fund for Ukraine.
2. Privilege Ukraine’s Donors
Extend public risk-sharing only to Ukraine‘s wartime donors.
3. Trust Institutions
Rely on donor governance and development bank expertise.
4. Expand Export Credits
Enhance the resources and broaden the scope of national export credit agencies.
5. Allow for National Solutions
Insure national investors against war risk in Ukraine.
6. Keep Tariffs Suspended
Make EU and US market access permanent for Ukrainian goods and services.
Leapfrogging Into a Net-Zero Ukraine
Expand All7. Create an Electricity Market
Extend the future EU CBAM to cover Ukrainian electricity exports to the EU.
8. Trade with Emission Rights
Include Ukraine’s electricity production sector in the EU ETS
9. Enhance Energy Efficiency
Quickly adopt ambitious energy efficiency standards in Ukraine
10. Better Efficiency, More Aid
Assistance should come with conditions on energy efficiency
Making Russia Pay the Legal Way
Expand All11. Manage Frozen Assets
Invest Russia’s frozen public funds and accept investment risk.
12. Prepare Claims
Establish an international claims commission for Ukraine.
13. Seize Private Funds
Adjust laws to enable legal seizure of Russian private assets.
14. Stay United
Preserve transatlantic unity to minimize risks of retaliation.
15. Be Realistic About Timeline
Do not expect Russian assets to quickly contribute to Ukraine’s reconstruction.
Ensuring Transparency and Accountability
Expand All16. Reforms First
Align donors around priority anti-corruption reforms.
17. Upgrade Technology
Ensure that donors use cutting-edge transparency tools.
18. Civil Society at the Table
Form a Ukrainian civil society advisory board.
19. Devolve Power
Preserve decentralization and empower local governments.
20. Improve Oversight
Create a Kyiv-based fusion cell of auditors.
Organizing Donors to Do Big Things
Expand All21. Embrace Leadership
Empower the coordination platform.
A MARSHALL PLAN FOR UKRAINE
We Need a Marshall Plan for Ukraine.
The Marshall Plan was an audacious, innovative strategy to tackle the most pressing challenges of its time. Breaking Western Europe’s cycle of conflict and rebuilding economies devastated by World War II was an immense task, and the Marshall Plan is a concrete example of the scale of change made possible by imagination, pragmatism, and generosity. GMF’s work carries this spirit into the 21st century.
#UkraineAlliance
GMF is a proud partner of the European Alliance of Cities and Regions for the Reconstruction of Ukraine.